The authors used ECN data for two sites in Scotland to reveal correlations between declining ground beetle (Coleoptera: Carabidae) populations and phenological changes (the timing of natural events).


Reference

Pozsgai, G. and Littlewood, NA. (2014). Ground beetle (Coleoptera: Carabidae) population declines and phenological changes: is there a connection? Ecological Indicators, 41, 15-24. DOI: 10.1016/j.ecolind.2014.01.029


Abstract

Long-term monitoring data were analyzed to reveal correlations between declining ground beetle (Coleoptera: Carabidae) populations and phenological changes at two Environmental Change Network sites in Scotland. The potential role of advancing phenology as an adaptation function in population stability was investigated.

Analysis focussed on the 25 most abundant species over an 18 year sampling period. Pitfall trap catches were used to calculate mean activity-densities both for the whole sampling period and for dates limited to those within the activity period. Several phenological measurements were calculated (i.e. first day of appearance, peak activity date, median activity, length of activity and winter inactivity periods, and the last day of presence) for each species. Robust non-parametric estimation was used to model changes in both activity density and phenology.

Eight species declined in activity density over time, three increased and fourteen showed no change. The mean rate of decline was greater than that of increase.

Most of the species included in the analysis changed their phenology. Advancing onset of activity and earlier cessation were the most pronounced changes. However, a slow advancing trend in the peak activity was also shown. Only Nebria brevicollis, an autumn species with recorded winter activity, extended its activity period to later dates, suggesting that cessation of activity for the remaining species may be more closely linked to photoperiod. The earlier termination of activity shortened substantially the activity window for several species.

Declines in activity density showed a strong relationship with a narrowing window of activity, mainly caused by earlier cessation of activity. Declining species were found more in bog or dry heather moorland habitats compared to grassland, emphasizing the vulnerability of these vegetation types, and associated insect assemblages depending on them, to environmental or climatic changes. The reciprocal relationship found between the trend of timing of initiation of activity and changes in activity-densities suggests that populations with a higher capacity to advance their phenology are less prone to decline. Since phenological changes may drive changes in populations, investigating phenological variables is encouraged in both research and conservation planning.


Why this research matters

This paper is relevant to the following issues:

  • Climate change
  • Biodiversity protection

In brief

On larger screens, step through the captioned images below in this order

Gallery viewing order icon

In more detail

Carabid beetles are important components of terrestrial food webs, and changes in their populations may affect other species in an ecosystem (such as the prey species that carabids feed on). Significant decreases in the abundance of several carabid species have been found in this and in other studies.

The authors of this paper investigated changes in the abundance and phenology (i.e. the timing of certain life-cycle events) of carabid species. Well-known examples of phenology include the timing of tree bud opening, the arrival of migratory species, and the timing of frog spawning. Temperature is commonly a controlling factor, and recent climate change has already resulted in phenological changes in some species.

Many species are dependent on other species and their phenological patterns have evolved to be tightly synchronised. When timings shift in response to changes in the environment, mismatches may have a negative impact. For example, a prey species may become less abundant, adversely affecting predator survival. Impacts may be exacerbated by other changes, such as loss of suitable habitat.

To investigate changes in carabid abundance and phenology, the authors used ECN data for the 25 most abundant carabid beetles, collected over 18 years (1994-2011) from lines of pitfall traps at two ECN Scottish ECN sites, Sourhope and Glensaugh.

They found that eight of the 25 species decreased significantly in number between 1994 and 2011. One species, Pterostichus adstrictus, almost completely disappeared from the samples by 2011, despite being recorded in large numbers in the early years. The populations of thirteen species at the sites were regarded as being stable, whilst four species were captured more frequently over time. The general decline in ground beetles is in line with findings at other ECN sites (see Morecroft et al., 2009 and Brooks et al., 2012). There is some evidence from this study that beetle species favouring bog and dry heather moorland declined more than those that favour grassland habitats.

The authors found significant changes in some of the phenological measures they considered. For example, the first day of appearance advanced for seven species and became later for two species. The length of the activity period decreased for four species and increased for two species. Overall, 10 species advanced their activity, as measured by at least one of the phenological measures. Similar advances have been reported for plants, fish and birds. The authors suggest that, at least in the case of carabid beetles, this advancement of activity may be a result of a tendency towards milder winters.

Determining the precise cause of changes in phenology is difficult, since there are many factors to consider. For example, some species have two or more distinct periods of activity. Some species hibernate in the winter while others remain active. Temperature, day length, body size and the type and abundance of prey species all influence the timing of activity, and vary from species to species.

Declining species were found more in heathland habitats (a grouping of bog and dry heather moorland habitats) compared with grassland, emphasizing the vulnerability of heathland vegetation types, and associated insect assemblages depending on them, to environmental or climatic changes.

To answer the question in the title of this paper, is there a connection between carabid beetle population declines and phenological changes, the answer appears to be yes. Earlier initiation of activity appeared to be advantageous for some species, whilst declines in abundance showed a strong relationship with a narrowing window of activity, mainly caused by earlier cessation of activity.